[Tartarus]

I made these two, I would like to know what everybody thinks.

[Joe Kerr]

This is my humble opinion. Before you read this know that i am a fail at graphics so i couldn't give a great rate if i tried to. I am rating off of what i feel and think when i look at the image.

The first one looks cool. The depth is ok and the color is a bit off to my eyes.

About the second one. No offense but i think it is a fail. It is much better than i could do so i give you credit but you couldn't win anything with the second one. The main thing is the border. Also i don't like the colors coming off the guy.

Over all i would give the first one and the second